The Social Dusseldorf court has now, in two cases (case no 547/10 AS S 29, S 29 AS 412/10) held that the consortium Make amounts of Hartz IV recipients to private health insurance in the full amount required if a change in the statutory health insurance is not possible, and if the insurance in the private health insurance at the best price. The defendant ARGEN had approved in each case only a grant in the amount of the contribution to the health insurance.
As justification, the SG Dusseldorf § 26 paragraph 2 sentence 2 SGB II approach taken in application. It is the intention of the legislature to ensure the affected full health insurance coverage, without which they would be charged against their will by contributing. "Therefore, in the interests of insurance customers mit denen privat Versicherter vergleichbar. Ansonsten würden nämlich bei den privat Versicherten Beiträge auflaufen, die letztlich nicht hinnehmbar das Existenzminimum gefährden würden.
Die Urteile sind bislang nicht rechtskräftig.
Bestätigt hat diese Auffassung jedoch das Landessozialgericht NRW in einer aktuellen Eilentscheidung , ein der es allerdings zugleich klargestellt hat, dass es Versicherten demgegenüber auch zumutbar ist, innerhalb To change the private health insurance in an offered by this favorable base rate.
